the two lawsuits explained

Lawsuit 2.

by Dave Thomas

As C is in week 10, a habeas corpus suit has been filed appealing to the US Federal District #3 Court to release C from the confines of KYC naming Lawrence County CYS and Cray Youth and Family Services Inc (KYC) as defendants.

The Education Law Center, Philadelphia, has also filed suit in US Federal District #3 Court naming New Castle Area School District responsible for not providing education for C while incarcerated at KYC. During the last 10 weeks C has been provided no education commensurate with his rights in violation of the McKinney-Vento Act.

Conditions at Krause Youth Center (KYC)

C has been jailed since April 3, 2015 having committed no crime, nor has he been adjudicated delinquent in any legal proceeding. He is being punished by Judge Motto, Lawrence County PA Court of Common Pleas, for refusing Motto’s order to return to his mother’s home where he has been abused by mother and her family. C has chosen jail over living with his mother where he is likely to be abused.

One of the issues is PA law provides that incarcerated minors without criminal history are not to be integrated with those jailed as criminal offenders. Contrary to law, C has been jailed in an integrated facility by Judge Motto.

C, although in custody of CYS, has been denied any personal freedom, denied education, and denied pursuit of religion. His caretakers have even denied C a haircut.

June 3, C was assaulted by an inmate at KYC. Fortunately he sustained no major injury.

The habeas corpus suit has provided an insight to daily conditions C endures at KYC:

  • he may not wear shoes, may not have a belt, no books, no toothbrush, no comb or brush or use of a mirror
  • one hot meal/day with insufficient food resulting in inmates regularly going hungry
  • mail is withheld by staff for days at a time even though regularly delivered by USPS.
  • 1 hour/week visitation by a parent only; and under supervision of CYS–no private conversations
  • incoming and outgoing mail is searched and read/and or copied by KYC staff
  • he may not have visitation of family, friends, teachers, etc.
  • permitted one letter /week, outgoing, which is commonly held for days by KYC
  • windows are covered at all times so no one can see outside
  • movements are restricted by staff including going to bathrooms and sleeping quarters, which are only accessible under the direct supervision of guards
  • he is forbidden from moving around in common rooms; and may not move to a different seating area or change seated positions without first seeking permission from the guards
  • he is forbidden to communicate with other inmates except with the permission of guards and within their direct supervision
  • subject to random searches of his person which can include body cavity searches
  • must adhere to a fixed daily schedule regimented by the guards which includes 3 hours of school, time to eat, time to sleep
  • outdoor exercise is permitted no more than 4 days/week
  • outdoor exercise facility consists of only a basketball hoop
  • outside exercise area is enclosed by a high chain link fence which until a few days ago had inside and outside barbed wire atop.  The barbed wire brackets are still atop the fence
  • there are no indoor exercise facilities, whatsoever
  • one timed 7 minute shower/day in one of 3 shower stalls—only one of which has hot water
  • 9 “Krause Bucks” maximum can be earned /week for behavior and chores. 3 “bucks” can be redeemed for a dessert or a treat; 7 “bucks” can get an extra 15 minute cold shower on Saturday if you are in line soon enough

Violation of McKinney-Vento Act

The second Federal suit has been filed by the Education Law Center of Philadelphia on behalf of C against the New Castle Area School District (NCASD) for not providing education for C since April 3 in violation of the McKinney-Vento Act.

Judge Motto’s order remanding C to KYC did not address or direct C be educated in any way.  KYC has provided no education commensurate with C’s needs as an 8th grade honors student.  The only education provided is by a K-6 certified teacher in a one-room school house environment, 3 hours/day where students range from 10-18 years old. His instruction was 7½ hours/day at his former school.

McKinney-Vento provides states with funding for educating “sheltered” or incarcerated youth and mandates the local school district is responsible for providing their education. NCASD has violated the Act by not providing C or any of the other inmates an opportunity for classroom education to prepare them for further education.


Dave Thomas is a retired electric utility operations manager, has been married for over 50 years to a woman who has served as a church secretary for over two decades. They presently live in Florida after living in same Pennsylvania community for 33 years. He is a former member of the Rotary International, Chamber of Commerce, and various state and national professional organizations.


Previous installments of this unfolding story can be read here (1), here (2), here (3), here (4), here (5) and here (6).

Although it is not a part of the story of C, this is another story about the corrupt courts of Lawrence County. And then, of course, there is the thoroughly outrageous story of Jordan Brown, consisting of many posts, but summarized here.


Groove of the Day

Listen to George Harrison performing “Sue Me, Sue You Blues”


Weather Report

93° and Clear


8 Responses to “the two lawsuits explained”

  1. June 10, 2015 at 1:12 pm

    We knew already much about the “prisons for profit” but Krause Youth Shelter seems to be a model of the kind. And it is in such a place that Motto and his minions dare send kids, even if they are small offenders? More serious, a kid who broke no law, if it is to refuse to comply with a judicial decision which he understood that it would endanger him if he did? One wonders how these types can sleep on their ears, attend Church and declare themselves good Christians, claim they represent the justice. Do they know the sense of this word?

    I sincerely hope that the lawsuits at Federal level will quickly lead to an improvement of the situation for C, and maybe even for the other children imprisoned in this place. And I come even to hope that Motto and his companions soon discover the joys of prison life, when wearing an orange jumpsuit.

  2. 2 Dave henderson
    June 10, 2015 at 10:31 pm

    It is very hard to believe that in the good old USA that this can continue to go on. My hope and prayer is the judge and others responsible for this travesty are held responsible and spend time like C is being forced to endure. It is time for sanity to take hold!

  3. 3 BobH
    June 11, 2015 at 12:28 am

    This is truly scandalous. But because it is perpetrated on a minor, no scandal will emerge without a combination of law and media.

  4. 4 len
    June 11, 2015 at 5:13 am

    as an american living in europe, even by eastern european standards, this treatment, of any minor, let alone one who has not been found guilty of any particular offense, other than the one outlined above, is barbaric and should be investigated at every possible level,
    and those responsible for this situation brought to task. our thoughts and prayers go out to C and his family.

  5. 5 Vonda Mishler
    June 16, 2015 at 11:57 pm

    I appreciate everything you write as your son texts me when prayer is needed, but I try not to bother him much otherwise.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: